Elsies Sub Shop | Sandwiches in Red Bank

Elsie's Sub Shop

Halloween Hours for Oct 31, we close at 3pm

Online Pickup Menu

7

You tried the rest now Taste the best!

One does not stay in business for over 50 years unless one has a great product that stands the test of time.

ELSIE’S MENU

1. Spiced Ham, Cooked Salami & Provolone

2. Boiled Ham, Cappacola & Provolone

3. Super-1 & 2 combo

4. Roast Beef

5. Turkey with Mayo & Cranberry

6. American Cheese

7. Whopper - EXTRA MEAT Super Combo

8. Bologna & Cheese

9. Provolone Cheese

10. Tuna Fish

11. Elsie's Deluxe - Roast Beef, Turkey, Ham, Cap, & Prov

12. Meatball Sub

13. Sausage Sub - Sweet Italian

14. Pepperoni & Provolone

15. Italian Sub - Ham, Salami & Provolone

16. Italian Sub - Ham, Salami, Cappacola & Provolone

17. Boiled Ham, Turkey & Swiss

18. Plain Jane - Just Lettuce, Tomato & Onion

19. All Cheese- Swiss

20. Chicken Parm

21. Pastrami - Hot or Cold

22. Hamburger Sub

23. Eggplant Parm Sub

24. Veggie Burger

25. Corned Beef

26. Sloopy Moe-Joe - Roast Beef, Turkey, Corned Beef, Swiss, Russian & Slaw

27. Pizza Sub - Pepperoni, Cheese & Sauce

28. Pizza Burger

29. Red Bank Rueben - Roast Beef with Russian & Slaw

30. Classic Rueben - Corned Beef or Pastrami

31. Tuna Melt

32. Hot Shot - Salami, Pepperoni, Cappacola & Prov with Hot Peppers

33. Club Sub - Turkey, Ham & Bacon

34. Turkey & Bacon

35. Mega- Veggie - Cheese, Pickles, Olives, L,T,O, O/V or Dressing

36. Fish Fillet

37. Gyro Sub

38. Chicken Elsie - Breaded Cutlet Topped with Blue Cheese

39. B.L.T

40. Chicken Salad

41. Egg Salad

42. Pork Roll & Cheese

43. Turkey & Roast Beef

44. Turkey, Salami & Cheese

45. Bootleg Cheese Steak - Hot Roast Beef & Cheese

46. Genoa Salami & Provolone

47. Genoa Salami, Cappacola & Provolone

48. Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub - Breaded Cutlet with Ham and Melted Swiss

49. BBQ Chicken Sub

50. BELLY BUSTER - Double Bacon Burger with Chili & Cheese

Select Your Condiments

Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Oil & Vinegar, Hot Peppers, Mayo, Banana Peppers, Pickles, Olives

Turn your sandwich to a “Pickle Sub” for $1.25 extra

Upgrade Your Sandwich to a Wrap- $1.00 Extra

Download Menu

Some of Our Most Requested

5. Turkey w/Mayo & Cranberry

Stacked with mounds of fresh roasted turkey, mayo, cranberry sauce, lettuce, & tomatoes.

15. Ham, Salami, & Provolone

An Italian classic on fresh baked bread loaded with all the fixin’s !!

2. Ham, Cappacola, & Provolone

One of our favorites with lettuce, tomato, onion, oil & vinegar – Yum!!!

The Pickle Sub

Trying to cut back on carbs? Meet the pickle sub! Any sub on the menu can be made on a pickle.

Fresh Wraps & SANDWICHES

A great wrap or sandwich has to start with the highest quality of meats, cheeses, breads, lettuce, and tomatoes. Add to that our special mixture of oil, vinegar, and Italian seasoning (our secret family recipe) and you’ll understand why folks always come back to Elsie’s.

Give Us a Call

OUR STORY

Before Neil Armstrong landed on the moon, there was Elsie’s Sub Shop. If you could travel back in time to 1959 when the store opened its doors and then awake years later to today, you would still know where you were. The technology certainly changed, but folks craving good and delicious food have not. Elsie’s has stood the test of time, serving great sandwiches, salads, and soups for more than half a century.

The current owner, Tish Reddington bought Elsie’s in 1989 when she was 23. It has the same feel of a local small-town store where everyone knows your name (and many do) that it had when it first opened.

“Everyone loves the place, It’s small, It’s very fun. We make you feel at home.” – Tish Reddington